Reading Guide

Rage Is Back

Rage Is Back


In 1987, Billy Rage was the most celebrated graffiti artist in New York City, leader of the Immortal Five crew and archenemy of NYPD Vandal Squad Officer Anastacio Bracken. After a fatal encounter with Bracken deep in the tunnels of New York’s subway system, Rage fled the city, leaving behind a slain friend, a mourning graffiti scene, and a baby boy, Kilroy Dondi Vance. Rage Is Back by Adam Mansbach brings Rage’s feud with Bracken into 2005, chronicling the conclusion of the two men’s battle for New York and the father–son relationship that is drawn into and deeply altered by the fight.

The now–teenaged Dondi, kicked out of his home and out of his prestigious prep school, is living off the generosity of friends after another battle with his mother. As aimless and frustrated as he is creative and smart, Dondi is bitter over Rage’s absence and burdened by the reputation of his mysterious, legendary father. When word spreads that Rage has returned and is marking his presence in the city with tribal chalk drawings scrawled on subway tunnel walls, both Dondi and Bracken—now chief of the Metropolitan Transit Authority—take notice.

In hallucinogenic first–person prose filled with wild, fascinating digressions, opinions, and the history of the graffiti scene, the young Dondi tells a story that is part urban fiction, part youthful fantasy—big city cynicism dosed with the extraordinary. Dondi is a compelling, complicated narrator, embodying the contradictory nature of teenage boys; he is by turns wry, self–deprecating, bold, and tender, Holden Caulfield by way of Brooklyn and one of the most nuanced young urban voices to arrive in a long time.

Soon Rage’s intentions in returning are clear: expose Bracken’s murderous past and thwart his run for mayor of the city Rage loves. He and the remaining members of the Immortal Five plan the greatest graffiti heist imaginable, drawing artists from around the world. In the span of a few hours, they aim to cover every subway car in the city with graffiti, spraying the name of the friend Bracken killed over and over again and looping a message to commuters over the PA system, detailing Bracken’s guilt. Rage is determined to destroy Bracken’s career—or destroy himself trying.

Rage Is Back is a love letter to the heart of New York, and the graffiti artists, small–time gangsters, and neighborhoods unknown to those outside the five boroughs of the city. Mansbach’s novel, written in the vernacular of the graffit community, provides a glimpse into a vibrant and exciting world and is certain to become one of the classic New York City novels.


Adam Mansbach’s books include the No. 1 New York Times bestseller Go the F**k to Sleep, the California Book Award—winning novel The End of the Jews, and the cult classic Angry Black White Boy. His work has appeared in The New Yorker, The New York Times Book Review, Esquire, and The Believer, and on National Public Radio’s All Things Considered.


Q. In the acknowledgments you thank a number of actual graffiti artists. How did you forge connections with this community?

Over many years. I wrote this book as an outgrowth of those relationships, rather than the other way around. When I got into hip–hop, around 1986, all the artistic elements were of a piece: the verbal (rhyming), the sonic (deejaying), the kinetic (b–boying), and the visual (graff). I was mainly an MC and a DJ, but you had to be conversant in all those forms and understand the ways they connected aesthetically. So I wrote a little bit—took tags, tried my hand at piecing under the names JUST and EASEL.

I wasn’t a natural at graffiti, but I became a connoisseur. The way it dealt with flow and rupture, the intricate rules and mores of the art and the competition, the interplay between creation and destruction—all that fascinated me. And graff writers were usually the most interesting hip–hoppers: the weirdos, the mad scientists, the guerillas, the theorists, the addicts. They’d invented this thing that made them outlaws, that they pursued at their own risk, strictly for fame and satisfaction. There’s a beautiful purity to it. So I made myself a student of its colorful, often apocryphal history, and got to know as many writers as I could, including legends like PHASE 2 and ZEPHYR and PART ONE.

By the time I conceived of this book, those friendships were solid. Before I started writing, I remember, I took KET ONE out to lunch and told him I needed to know whether it would be possible to paint every train in the NYC subway system in one night, and if so, how it could be done. He leaned across the table and said, “I’ve been thinking about this for twenty years.”

Q. It seems that graffiti has existed for as long as there has been written culture; there are even ancient Roman examples of graffiti, often of the type found in a bathroom stall. What accounts for the enduring appeal of writing graffiti?

The purity of the statement. It’s literature in its rawest form: a simple declaration of existence, adorned and armored and fractured and stylized in every imaginable way. It’s no coincidence that modern graffiti culture developed around the name, or that the practitioners call themselves writers. Graffiti is narrative; it tells a story, if you know where to look.

Q. Dondi isn’t shy about sharing opinions on actual people and events. For example, the book Tuesdays with Morriereceives a few less than flattering comments. Were you concerned that you might offend anyone?

No. I’m writing in a voice, and the novel succeeds or fails on the authenticity and humor and heart of that voice. Dondi is a sharp, shit–talking eighteen–year–old stoner, and I was having too much fun to rein him in at all. Generally speaking, I think honesty of the sort that underwrites good literature is incompatible with worrying about causing offense. Plus, Mitch Albom’s probably not gonna read this book.

Q. From the first page, the novel is written in the vernacular of the graffiti crew, and the reader either understands it, appreciates it, and follows it or he doesn’t. Was there ever a concern that the language might be an impediment for some readers?

I was only concerned with getting the voice right. And I don’t see it as particularly inaccessible—I mean, it’s English, and it’s grammatically correct. Yes, Dondi mashes up slang and high cultural classicism, so maybe some readers won’t get the Greek mythology references and others won’t know some hip–hop touchstones. But that kind of easy, flowing multilinguistic pastiche is how he gets down—how a whole lot of people I know get down. His signposts are as legitimate and mainstream as any other set, they’re just underrepresented in literature. The way I was taught to approach books at my fancy Ivy League college is that if you don’t understand something, you do the work of figuring it out. You look up the obscure reference, or the Spanish word, and you learn something. Language is changing all the time, after all. Am I ranting? I feel like I’m ranting. I’ll stop now.

Q. New York City is more than the setting for the novel—it’s a mythic presence; the novel could not take place in any other city. Why does New York hold this sway over people?

Because it’s a festering, majestic shithole full of compressed energy and dreams and tension and innovation. At the population density of Manhattan, you could fit the world’s population into the state of Texas. Put people from all over the world on top of each other like that and some fly shit is bound to pop off. In terms of this book, New York is the nexus of graffiti culture, the birthplace of hip–hop. There’s an exceptionalism that goes with that—sometimes it sours into provincialism, but often it just gives New Yorkers an unmatched wit and swagger.

Q. In the 1970s and 1980s, New York was a dark and foul place, riddled with crime, urban squalor, and, of course, graffiti. Some people, including those in the novel, feel that this period was the “true” New York, as opposed to what they perceive as the gentrified, sanitized New York of today. On pages 216-217, Dondi admits seeing both sides of this issue but declines to argue for either. What is your opinion?

It’s important not to romanticize the governmental neglect, institutional racism, and other insidious factors that created the climate you’re talking about. The circumstances out of which graffiti and hip–hop rose were deplorable, and represent failed policies on a municipal and a national level. That said, to position gentrification as the opposite creates a false dichotomy. There are losers and winners in gentrification, and the losers are the same people who lost in the ’70s—the poor and disenfranchised. We have to look at whether gentrification lifts everybody’s quality of life, or just makes a neighborhood uninhabitable by its longtime residents. Ditto the “sanitized” New York: that process mirrors a national trend toward record–setting levels of incarceration. We’ve moved from the politics of abandonment to the politics of containment, but neither one is worth celebrating.

Q. When describing the time–traveling properties of the apartment stairs, Dondi says that if the readers are hoping for magical realism, then they should move on to a different book. However, magical realism is usually defined as a narrative style in which fantastical elements appear in a reality–based context. Doesn’t that description fit Dondi’s supernatural staircase or the possibility of supernatural forces in the subway tunnels?

Yeah, but he still rejects the term—because he considers it corny, and “literary,” and his life is real. Personally, I was interested in thinking about what a contemporary, New York magic realism would look like. You know, we read Márquez and understand that his magic realism is grounded in the religion of Colombia, or we read Murakami and understand that his version is based in Japanese myth and culture . . . but we don’t have any such framework in this country. So for me, what it looks like is that the incidents of “magic” don’t go unremarked upon. Rather, they have to be defended and debated, and when you tell somebody about them, the reaction is usually like, “get the fuck outta here with that bullshit.”

Q. Are there any classic New York films or novels that influenced you when writing Rage Is Back?

I’d say that the biggest literary influences on this novel were Rule of the Bone by Russell Banks, 2666 by Roberto Bolano, and maybe Treasure Island. But the music of New York City—from classic hip–hop to Nuyorican salsa to jazz—is always with me in an important way, no matter what I’m working on.

Q. Late in the novel, Dondi describes the process of writing his book as “Fake it till you make it, as they say. Keep sitting in that chair” (page 288). Is that your own approach to writing?

The “keep sitting in the chair” part, for sure. I’m happy to say that I don’t feel like I’m faking it anymore. Although that probably means I’m faking it.

Q. You write in a number of different genres, including poetry and your bestselling children’s book parody, Go the F**k to Sleep. Is there a particular medium that you feel most comfortable in? Were you expecting that the parody would be the success that it was? What was that experience like?

Shit, just when I was thinking I could get out of this without talking about Go the Fuck to Sleep. No, I wasn’t expecting that book to take off and sell a million copies; I was just tickled that I got to publish it. The experience was crazy; I literally did eight hours of interviews every single day for six months, and I’ve got far too many wacky stories to get into here, from the New Zealand censorship battle to my face–off with Dr. Ferber.

At heart, I’ll always be a novelist, and an MC. But the nice thing is that compared to the heavy lifting of a novel—the time, the commitment, the word count, the world–creation—everything else feels relatively light . . . which is not to say that I’m good at it, just that it takes a lot out of me. But I’ve been doing more screenwriting lately, and I find that a joy. Poetry is always fun. Genre fiction, which is new to me, is a blast, too. I like to work within parameters sometimes—the strictures of meter and rhyme, or the imperative to end each chapter with a cliffhanger—because it’s a fun challenge to create inside these constraints.

Q. What is your next project? Are you working in different genres simultaneously?

I have a supernatural thriller called The Dead Run coming out in July—my first genre novel. I’m supposed to do a second, too; that one is called Blood Alcohol Content. I’ve got about three movie projects in various stages of development, too, including a script I got to workshop last year at the Sundance Screenwriters Lab, and another that Jim Jarmusch is executive producing. And this week, a script I wrote for a pro–Obama video called Wake the Fuck Up will shoot—Samuel L. Jackson is starring in it. That will probably be out by the time you read this.


  1. What was your opinion of graffiti before reading this book? Has your opinion changed in any way?

  2. Some artists such as Banksy and Shepard Fairey use the medium of graffiti to create work that is considered “high art” and respected by critics and the public. Fairey’s portrait of Obama, for example, was used in the 2008 presidential campaign. If you’re unfamiliar with their work, take a moment to look it up. What do you think of it? Why is their graffiti treated differently from the type of work described by Mansbach?

  3. Dondi strains against the rules of society in ways both large and small. Have you ever broken the law? Challenged authority? Rebelled against the expectations placed on you by parents?

  4. Rage Is Back plays with the typical narrative form. The majority of chapter 8 is taken up by Theo Polhemus’s short story, and Cloud 9 narrates chapter 10. How did this affect your engagement with the story? Why did Mansbach do this?

  5. Dondi says that “rupture is . . . hardwired into everything my parents’ generation of New Yorkers built” (page 229). What does he mean?

  6. Many of the characters are more sympathetic than one might expect; some are darker than they first seem. Which characters did you respond to in ways that surprised you?

  7. Dondi struggles to understand his father. Do you believe that Billy is a good man? Explain.

  8. Although Bracken is the dark counterpart to Billy’s hero, he appears very few times in the novel. What were his motives in pursuing graffiti artists in general, and Billy in particular? Was there something otherworldly in the tunnels that influenced his behavior?

  9. On page 274, Dondi admits that he wants to be recognized as the kind of person who is “pointed at, whispered about.” How does this play into his feelings toward his father, who is just such a person?

  10. Karen is the only prominent female character, but she more than holds her own against all the male graffiti artists. What was your response to her? At one point, Dondi mentions that she had a psychotic break due to exhaustion from worrying about his health. Is the resulting psychological imbalance demonstrated in the course of the book?

  11. What if Billy Rage had stayed in New York after the death of Amuse? Would Dondi and Karen have benefited from his presence in their lives?